Go to content

Do NOT Follow the Lights | Alternating Hand Practice - Cairns' Style - Comfort in Every Bar. Certain in Every Key.

Giselle Anna Cairns provides classical piano pieces with bar-by-bar videos, ergonomic fingering, play alongs, and much more
Skip menu
Cairns' News
10 November 2026

Do NOT Follow the Lights
My dear Piano Lovers,

Playing the piano can be a deeply rewarding adventure, provided you are not led astray by well-meaning but counterproductive practice advice.

In the world of piano pedagogy, we often encounter methods that sound terribly logical on paper, yet completely contradict how the human brain and body actually learn music.
One such piece of advice—often recommended for tricky polyrhythms, though applied to simpler passages as well—suggests a constant cycle of alternating hand practice: Right hand alone, left hand alone, hands together, and repeat.

As an independent piano teacher specialising in ergonomic piano pedagogy, I have a very clear message for you whenever you come across this kind of instruction: Do NOT follow these lights.

While practising hands separately certainly has its place at the very beginning when decoding a new score, intentionally reverting to single-hand practice after you have already started putting your hands together is a massive step backward. Let me explain why this very approach fails you in a neurological, architectural, and biomechanical way.

The Neurological Perspective: Do Not Tear Down Your Own Wiring
Learning a piece of music is essentially a process of building new neural pathways. When you coordinate both hands, your brain is not merely running two separate tracks simultaneously; it is constructing a single, unified "data line" that governs the complex interaction between both hemispheres.

Every time you stop playing together to isolate one hand again, you interrupt this delicate process. Instead of reinforcing your newly built neural network, you are effectively tearing down your own data lines for the sake of a "safety check."

This constant switching prevents your movement from ever becoming truly automatic.

The Architectural Perspective: Never Rebuild the Scaffolding
Imagine building a grand stone arch. During construction, you undoubtedly need a wooden scaffold (hands-separate practice) to hold the individual stones in place until the keystone is set.

Once that keystone is in and the musical structure stands on its own (hands-together practice), the arch supports itself through mutual pressure and balance.

Going back to hands-separate practice at this stage is like rebuilding the wooden scaffolding around a finished stone arch just to test the stability of a single stone.

Why, in piano’s name, should you do that? Trust the structure you have built, let the mutual balance of both hands carry the sound, and refine it as a whole.

The Biomechanical Perspective: Making One Hand "Unemployed"
From an ergonomic standpoint, playing a passage with one hand is a completely different choreographic event than playing it with two. Your body perceives balance, weight transfer, and torso alignment as one unified system.

When you suddenly make one hand "unemployed" during a practice cycle, your centre of gravity shifts. The moment you bring the second hand back onto the keyboard, your body experiences a sudden physical recalibration which might lead to an unnecessary strain.

Beware the Will-o'-the-Wisp: Trust the Cairn Instead
Did you ask yourself why I chose the title Do NOT Follow the Lights? In old Scottish Highland legends, travellers crossing lonely peat bogs at night were warned against the will-o'-the-wisp—mysterious bluish or yellowish flames dancing over the marsh.

Science tells us these lights are merely marsh gases igniting in the air; the moment a traveller chases them, the displaced air pushes the flame further away, leading the wanderer in circles until they sink into the bog.

Many traditional practice methods work in much the same way. They were often conceived for professional concert pianists who spend countless hours at the instrument every single day.

However, for a non-professional player who first and foremost wishes to see rewarding progress within a reasonable timeframe, chasing those flickering practice tricks can only lead into a musical swamp. Instead of testing such tips, why not rely on a solid stone landmark: a cairn?

For me, the surname Cairns itself stands for care and guidance. Thus, sensible practice means keeping your hands together once they have found their way.

Of course, you might have to play certain passages slowly before they settle in, and practise in small snippets to save your brain from a mental overload.

(No matter how easy or difficult a piece is for you, personally, making it your very own works best when your score provides reliable support in the first place—as I have explained in my articles on The De-Cluttered Piano Fingering and The Traffic-Jam-Free Piano Fingering.)

Do not let any expert lure you off your path when your own ergonomic comfort tells you otherwise.
Yours truly,
{Doing it Cairns' Style | Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key}
© 2026 Cairns' Style | Giselle Anna Cairns
Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key
Doing it Cairns' Style
Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key
Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key.
Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key
Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key
Back to content