Go to content

Making it Possible - Cairns' Style - Comfort in Every Bar. Certain in Every Key.

Giselle Anna Cairns provides classical piano pieces with bar-by-bar videos, ergonomic fingering, play alongs, and much more
Skip menu
The Blog
20 October 2026
last updated on 23 October 2026
Making it Possible
My dear Piano Lovers,

In my previous blog articles Really Tried and Tested? and The Missing Link I provided a few tips for one of Leopold Mozart's pieces for his son, the famous Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, and I have already got this far
Alternative optimised piano fingering solution by Giselle Anna Cairns for bars 1 to 8 of Leopold Mozart's Minuet in C, Doing it Cairns' Style
to the end of bar eight.

(N.B.: To avoid any unnerving scrolling, all images are inserted as often as deemed necessary by me, Giselle Anna Cairns.)

The Editorial Piano Fingering Bars 8 to 10
Even though the editor did not provide us with a fingering for the “D” in bar eight, I presume you remember that I proposed to strike this key with finger 1.

Complete overview of the original editor's piano fingerings for bars 8 to 11 of Leopold Mozart's Minuet in C before the pedagogical correction
But once again, you seemed to be required to begin a new phrase with a piano fingering which is, at least, open to discussion.

Why, in piano’s name, should you start a sequence of six neighbouring keys with Finger 5, knowing from the start that the sheer number of your fingers would not suffice?
Complete overview of the original editor's piano fingerings for bars 8 to 11 of Leopold Mozart's Minuet in C before the pedagogical correction
To be quite honest with you: I have really no idea at all.

This ending on “G” with finger 2 is no help at all in case you go back to the beginning and repeat or continue in bar 11, where you face an octave jump from the very same “G” to the “G” one octave above which has to be played with fingers 1 and 5 in quick succession.
Complete overview of the original editor's piano fingerings for bars 8 to 11 of Leopold Mozart's Minuet in C before the pedagogical correction
The Doing it Cairns‘ Style Piano Fingering
Therefore, I suggest to use a most natural solution to play these six keys in bars nine and ten by doing a finger over, quite as originally suggested by the unmasked editor, but at a different place, and begin on

the “E” with finger 3, further down to
the “D” with finger 2,
the “C” with finger 1 (this ends the triplet).
Alternative optimised piano fingering solution by Giselle Anna Cairns for bars 8 to 11 of Leopold Mozart's Minuet in C, Doing it Cairns' Style
Then you might execute a finger over and play

the crotchet “B” with finger 3,
the crotchet “A” with finger 2, and
the minim “G” with finger 1.
Alternative optimised piano fingering solution by Giselle Anna Cairns for bars 8 to 11 of Leopold Mozart's Minuet in C, Doing it Cairns' Style
A finger over from finger 1 to 3 should, however, ideally be executed in a way that finger 1 is placed far back on the edge of the white key—"C” in question—, allowing the longer finger 3 to literally slide past over the tip of finger 1 and position itself next to it, while finger 1 could still remain on the key. This might give you a visual help as to how far down finger 3 has to travel.

A far-out position of finger 1 at the edge of the white key should also prevent finger 3 from having to make an involuntary movement to prevent itself from bumping into a black key on its way down.

I believe you see what a difference it could make to spend some time over your piano fingering when the result so far is this:
Alternative optimised piano fingering solution by Giselle Anna Cairns for bars 1 to 11 of Leopold Mozart's Minuet in C, Doing it Cairns' Style
And in the next blog article I am going to finish the piano fingering for the right hand until the end of this piece.

Yours truly,
{Doing it Cairns' Style | Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key}
© 2026 Cairns' Style | Giselle Anna Cairns
Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key
Doing it Cairns' Style
Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key
Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key.
Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key
Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key
Back to content