Cairns' News
20 November 2026
To Kill Two Birds with One Stone
Or: Practise Piano Hands Together Without Stopping at the Bar Line and Get to Results in One Go
My dear Piano Lovers,
In my previous article, Do NOT Follow the Lights, I explained why returning to separate-hand practice after you have already begun playing hands together could tear down your newly built neural wiring. Instead, I recommended practising hands together slowly and in small snippets so your brain never suffers from mental overload.
Today, I would like to share one single, highly effective rule for defining those small snippets—a principle known as “one bar plus one beat”.
Never Treat the Bar Line Like a Stop Sign
When non-professional pianists practise a piece bar by bar, they almost always stop right before the bar line. Without realising it, they train their brains and fingers to treat every bar line like a red stop sign.
When they later try to play the piece from start to finish, that invisible brake kicks in every single time: there is a tiny hesitation, a stumble, or a sudden drop in tempo right before beat one of the next bar.
The "Bar Plus One" Rule: Overlap Your Practice Snippets
To eliminate this bar-line brake from the very first moment you put your hands together, avoid stopping at the end of a bar. Instead, practise one complete bar plus the very first note (or chord) of the following bar.
This approach is not new and it has been recommended by respected piano pedagogues before. However, knowing the rule is only one hand of a two-handed piece. Understanding why it works and how to stitch your snippets together is what truly makes the difference in your daily practice:
You build a bridge instead of a wall
Your fingers can immediately learn the physical movement across the bar line as part of the musical phrase, rather than treating the next bar as a brand-new obstacle.
You get double training on every transition
When your first snippet covers Bar One plus the first beat of Bar Two, and your next snippet covers Bar Two plus the first beat of Bar Three, you naturally practise that crucial arrival point twice—once as a destination, and once as a fresh starting point.
You support smooth line-to-line transitions
One of the most common stumbling blocks in sheet music is jumping from the end of one system to the beginning of the next line. By routinely practising the last bar of a line plus the first note of the new line, your eyes and hands bridge the visual gap before it turns into a habit of hesitating.
You encourage true musical independence
Practising overlapping snippets helps you break free from always having to start at the very beginning of a piece.
How to Stitch Your Snippets Together in Real Life
Practising tiny snippets is wonderful, yet many players get stuck when trying to connect them into longer passages. Because I cannot sit beside your piano bench to guide you in person, here are two Doing it Cairns’ Style™ ways to link your snippets safely without overwhelming yourself:
Build a Longer Runway (Working Backwards)
Suppose you have worked your way up to Bar Four plus the first beat of Bar Five, and that final snippet feels comfortable. Instead of going all the way back to Bar One, step back just one bar: start at Bar Three and play through to the first beat of Bar Five.
This gives you a longer "runway" into your newly learned bar while testing how reliably Bar Three is still sitting in your fingers. Once that feels steady, step back to Bar Two and play to the first beat of Bar Five—gradually adding earlier bars like dancers joining a chorus line.
Expand From Your Strongest Anchor
You do not always have to work chronologically from the beginning. Pick whichever snippet anywhere in the piece already feels safest and most comfortable to you. From that solid anchor, add just one bar plus one beat immediately after it—or add the bar right before it so it connects smoothly into your safe zone.
By expanding outward from what already works, you build confidence step by step instead of constantly battling the hardest spot cold.
Keep It Small, Keep It Flowing
Of course, you do not always have to limit yourself to a single bar; depending on the tempo and complexity of your piece, your snippet might be half a bar or two bars long. The guiding principle remains the same: include the first note across the boundary so your music is invited to flow naturally forward.
Combined with a clean, ergonomic layout—as I have shared in my thoughts on The De-Cluttered Piano Fingering and The Traffic-Jam-Free Piano Fingering—this thoughtful habit can help transform hesitant bar-by-bar practice into smoother, more confident playing.
Yours truly,
{Doing it Cairns' Style | Comfort in Every Bar & Certain in Every Key}